While making the changes to Mori’s code for 1.7, I encountered some oddities in test results, and it turned out there was a bug which I had introduced in an earlier release. While it doesn’t appear to endanger data in Mori notebooks, it might not return all the results you expect in a search, or in entry summaries.

In addition, it has what I hope are a couple of performance improvements, continued improvements to Italian localization, and a work-around for Leopard’s insistence to treat non-Apple Spotlight metadata files as third-class citizens.

Normally when Spotlight discovers a file has been created or changed, it will ask the responsible program to figure out what’s inside, and feed it back to Spotlight. But one of the drawbacks to Spotlight’s design is it lacks the ability to define containers, or documents which contain logically distinct elements such as the chapters of a book, pictures in a photo album, or entries from a Mori notebook; and which can nest other containers as well. Treating a document as a single entity, Spotlight will open a document at the beginning (or maybe the place where the cursor was the last time it was open), even if what you’re looking for is somewhere near the end.

Because it doesn’t understand that a file can have distinct elements, the development teams for other Apple software (e.g., iPhoto, Safari, Stickies, etc.) came up with a scheme to trick Spotlight by creating new files with the data for those elements. So that’s how Jesse coded Mori’s behavior: duplicate the data for that logically distinct element in its own file. A separate copy of each element’s data in its own file. One extra file per element. That means the space taken up by your data is easily half again more than if Apple just added a container definition for Spotlight metadata (once for the notebook, another for the entry metadata file, and the third copy in Spotlight’s database).

But that isn’t all. While we’d like to keep all those extra files inside a notebook bundle (a directory which Finder treats as a file), because Spotlight treats a document as a single element it won’t look for those files inside the bundle. So Mori creates those files in the metadata cache folder (in your Library/Caches/Metadata folder), along with the metadata files from some of Apple’s programs. If you open the metadata folder and look at these files, you’ll see they have numbers to help Mori figure out which entry contains that data. But when you do a search using the Spotlight menu, and when you select menu item ‘Show All’ and the results are displayed in the Finder, you won’t see the numbers; you’ll see the titles for the entries they represent.

Leopard however, isn’t so democratic; which is why users where complaining about the entries when Leopard was released. First off, it ignores any non-Apple metadata files in the cache folder unless you set your Spotlight preferences to use those files. Secondly, it will ignore the title info embedded in the entry metadata file and just display the file’s actual title, meaning the number. How’s that for Apple undermining the work of third-party developers?

So the workaround I came up with is to add the entry’s title (or Untitled, if it has none) at the beginning of the filename, so you at least have an idea which entry matches your search terms.

(Thanks for wasting about a whole month total of my development time on that alone, Apple. I feel the love.)

I am, of course, more than happy to eat crow should I be proven to be completely mistaken or speaking from out-dated information. It’s easily worth it in order to improve the user experience.

Regardless of the rationale for the design decisions, enjoy, and thank you for being part of the community and continuing to support Mori!