Mori for Research and Reference Notes

Tags ( )

Recently I’ve started to use Mori to make and organize research notes. I haven’t yet left off using Jabref as a bibliography and citation manager, but I need somewhere to store and retrieve my comments and ideas as I read through papers and books. My workflow is still very rudimentary, but I was encouraged to share it here, and hope that with some feedback and discussion it will become more refined.

The basic unit now is that for a single reference:

  • Johnson2000, the citation tag, reference title
    • paper, links to the pdf file
    • figures, representative figures from the work
    • notes, all the notes concerning the work, including figures and quotes
    • refs, other papers/books referred to by the work that might be worth looking into

Johnson2000

this entry serves as the header for the reference. I use a bibtex key (authorYear) as a unique identifier here, for the pdf file name (helps Jabref with auto matching citation to file), and in the citation manager.

I put my own keywords or tags in the note so that might notes will also come up under spotlight searches for the tags.

paper

in the paper note I put two things: 1) a link to the external file, 2) and an image reference to the file to accomplish #1

  1. type “paper” in the note and select it (or some appropriate tag)
  2. choose: Text -> Make Link…
  3. type in the path to the file

to accomplish #2

  1. drag the file from the Finder into the note field and push the control key before you release the drag
  2. the control key will make it a link to the file rather than a copy of the file

figures

Most of the papers I read include engineering diagrams and those diagrams become one of the most memorable impressions of the paper. When I have trouble remembering which paper described a certain process or technique, I often browse through papers looking for the figures I remember. Eventually, I would like to use some unix tools to extract and assemble image collages from the pdf’s automatically, but for now, I find that Quicksilver lets me do it manually without too much trouble. As I read through the paper, I continuously use cmd+shift+cntl+4 (I’m going to set my middle mouse button to this key combo) to screenshot figures to the clipboard. Once I’ve finished, I go back to Mori and activate Quicksilver’s clipboard module and drag all the images out into the “figures” note and to the Notes section if they relate to one of the comments I sent over through Note-chan (see below.)

notes

I use the script/app that I uploaded to the Scripts & Plugins section (called Note-chan) to take notes while I read a paper. It presents a small window that I can keep open adjacent to or on top of Preview or Safari, and type in my thoughts or comments about certain passages. You can also attach automatically clipboard contents to the note when you send it to Mori. All notes get sent to an “Inbox” (similar to the Quicksilver script posted by Leo)

refs

This is where I cut and paste any references cited in the work that I might also want to check out. I will probably link to them from here once they are into the notebook as their own reference.

Usage

It might seem inefficient to put all of these things in separate enteries that have identical names (e.g. every ref has a “figures” entry) but now I can have two smart folders set up, that will gather all of these entries and make it easy for me to very quickly browse through all the figures, for example.

Also I wrote a script that will automatically insert a new reference entry along with subentries based on a template (see “Prototype” under the Scripts and Plugins.)

Future Directions

I’m not sure how my use will evolve, but I’ve considered a number of things:

*an applet to automatically generate an entry and link to the file *improve Note-chan to allow the automatic attachment of images to my comments *full citation (probably bibtex) import and export

I would very much like to hear how others are using Mori in this regard (alone or in conjuction with other software.) Or if you have ideas for techniques or methods that could be implemented with additional features, we could also discuss how they might be implemented.

AttachmentSize
RefMan.jpg124.2 KB

For refs managment I use

For refs managment I use Sente, have a look.

Sente and BibDesk

I generally use LaTeX for my document preparation tasks. I find BibDesk a fine, open-source tool for managing my bibliographies.

What it lacks, and what Sente may provide, is an interface to the on-line databases of references. That would make literature searches of more recent materials a bit easier than my current process, which uses the tools provided by my library through a browser interface.

I'm going to give Sente a good hard look. Thanks for a good catch.

Bookends

Give Bookends a harder look than Sente. Sente has a nice interface and its column sorting is cool, but Bookends formatting and importing abilities squashes Sente in my opinion.

I have never used LaTex and BiBTeX so I can't really comment. But both Sente and Bookends work well together with Mellel.

I really like Mori, and like you I am hoping that it can work as a research tool. I recently sent a big long email to Jesse about possibly collaborating with Mellel and Bookends to form an academic writer's suite. There are two such suites for PC, Nota Bene and IdeaMason, but nothing of equivalence for Mac which is a real shame.

Devonthink isn't really interested in working with Mellel of Bookends, which has caused me to look elsewhere and is why i have landed in the Mori forums. I really have my fingers crossed about this, here's to hoping!

How sweep it would be to be able to search all of your notes, your bibliographic database(s) and your own document files in one search. There is a definite gap in the mac marketplace right now that Mori could fill if it hooked up with Mellel and Bookends.

One big thing Mori needs to implement first if a PDF reader and indexing PDF files. It is an absolute must if it is to be seriously considered as an academic tool.

Danny

sente/bookends

I use both sente and bookends (and endnote)

sente:
+: nice interface and spotlight indexing
-: problems with exports of accentued characters and notes

bookends
+ batch text modification in multiple entries (search/replace); standard format, no problem to export/import with endnote = more professional than sente

NoteChan supports Send to Inbox?

BMEguy, does this mean there is a new version of NoteChan that lets you send notes to a specified folder or "Inbox"? In my version it has a place holder for this setting but says, "This setting is not yet active." This is a feature that I would really like to have.

I think I have the latest version but I don't know how to check the version of the plugin.

Thanks,
Nate

Bookends, Devonthink and Scrivener

The main reason I stopped using Mori for my research was that it does not support a zoom setting for notes. Yes, you can increase the font size, but then you have to do a double dance everytime you go back and forth from Mori to your writing app.

Currently, I'm using DevonThink Pro. It does support zoom (so I don't have to squint when working with my MacBook), and it supports a wealth of other research-oriented features. Smooth handling of PDF files, for instance. Every PDF is indexed and becomes searchable right away. In addition, the new DevonThink Pro allows you to import scanned PDFs, which then OCRs, making them also searchable. That feature alone places DTP in a category of its own. I'm not bashing Mori at all. I use it for a number of things, but when I have to handle massive research notes and PDFs I have to go to DTP.

For bibliography management I use Bookends. It's very responsive, I has the fantastic Internet search, which has save me probably many hours of typing entries. I doesn't integrate exactly with DTP, but that it's not really a problem for me, becasue I use Scrivener to write papers, novels, short stories, and now my dissertation.

For a while, I was knocking on doors, requesting features, hoping that one developer would develop a complete academic-writing research environment, but I had no luck. It was for the better, because now I have three apps that work very well together when I need to write academic papers: DevonThink Pro, Boonends and Scrivener.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.